Progressive Field, Cleveland (The Problem With Problematic Team Nicknames)
What do you do with problematic team nicknames? The Cleveland Indians became the Cleveland Guardians before the 2022 season, one of the latest events in a long-running controversy over teams in all sports with nicknames based on Native Americans in one form or another. I want to explore that, but first, it’s worth noting that three major league teams have changed their names because of political correctness during my lifetime, and the Indians/Guardians is the first one related to the Native American issue. Some history The first team name change during my lifetime was in 1959, and was a change back to the long-time name after a political controversy had run its course. The Cincinnati team had been the “Reds” for decades, but in 1953, they changed it to “ Redlegs ” because “Reds” had become a politically sensitive word, used by U.S. Sen. Joe McCarthy and others as a slur for people they thought were Communists, or were not anti-Communist enough. The movie (more recently a...